I caught the Game of Thrones bug. Loved the TV show, and immediately went out and bought the first book after it all wrapped up. I'd had it recommended to me a few times before (the book, that is), and I even have a collection of George R.R. Martin's short stories sitting on my bookshelf collecting dust. Good stuff, no doubt, but it didn't drive me to obsession with the man. A Game of Thrones, on the other hand...wow. The man knows how to do an epic narrative. The plots are complex, the characters interesting, and despite the fact that it is VERY MUCH a fantasy novel (Christ, it starts with Ice Zombies), the entire thing, as many reviews have mentioned, feels more like a political drama than your typical swords-and-sorcery epic.
But that's not to say the book doesn't have its problems. While I was reading, I hit a wall about 4/5s of the way through, literally a hundred pages from the end. One chapter did me in. A Catelyn chapter. I just can't get behind her, as a character, which REALLY bugs me, considering on paper I think she actually seems fairly interesting. Here's a woman, a wife and mother, who sees nearly EVERYONE she loves taken away from her. It's a tragic arc, and it should be great. But it's not, and her chapters are just a slog to get through.
Part of the problem, I think, and part of the reason why I have such a hard time getting behind her character, is that there is frankly not much conflict inherent in her premise, or at least not much active, physical conflict that she herself is driving. Tyrion, Ned, and Jon are all wrapped up in very real struggles for power and fame and honor and their respective lives. Arya is trying to carve out her own place in a world that will not way accept her (not to mention surviving on the streets of King's Landing), Daenerys is rebuilding a home she never had, and Bran must come to terms with his new limitations. Even Sansa, who could very easily have suffered from the same problems as her mother, has a turbulent and active character arc. In fact, Sansa might be one of my favorite characters in the first book. She's an idealist, and the fact is Westeros, King's Landing, and the court of Prince Joffrey ARE going to break her. It's not if her romantic notions of her Prince Charming will fall apart, but rather when. It's a tragic arc in a way, the inevitable collision that you just can't help but watch.
Cat has none of this. Cat's arc is clearly grounded in family, and how she relates to her relatives and loved ones. They seem to drop like flies around her, and every time she must survive to pick up the pieces. But the problem is she doesn't DO anything. She spends the first third of the book literally sitting in a room watching a someone sleep, and the last third watching her son go to war. It's a lot of watching and frankly, for all that these events are critical to the plot, Catelyn's character feels entirely secondary to them. In fact, it often feels like she's simply an extra pair of eyes, watching important plot developments for us. She feels like a device and not a fully formed person, in a book that is practically bursting with real, human characters.
As a somewhat interesting aside, I found Cat to be a great character in the TV series. Sure, she was still passive, but we weren't forced to endure her narration whenever we went back to her storylines, something that I think made her a lot more tolerable. Michelle Fairley also deserves some credit here, as she's able to take a lot of the angst inherent in Cat's character and distill it to little, visual moments rather than multi-page blocks of text.
Admittedly, I'm only one book into a massive series, and a first book at that. Maybe Martin figured this all out in Clash of Kings. He is, after all, a fairly talented writer, as we have seen. But as it stands, every time I finish a chapter I turn the page dreading I'll find Catelyn's name on the next page.